
February 2005


Washington Diplomat
PO Box 1345
Wheaton, MD 20915
Tel: 301.933.3552
Fax: 301.949.0065
|
|



Swallowed by the Sea: South Asia Slowly Recovering
by Larry Luxner
At 7:48 p.m. local time on Dec. 25just as a killer tsunami generated by a magnitude 9.0 earthquake struck the western edge of his countryIndonesian Ambassador Soemadi D.M. Brotodiningrat was celebrating Christmas with several hundred fellow Indonesians at the Doubletree Hotel in Tysons Corner, Va.
Indias ambassador, Ronen Sen, was at the National Cathedral, attending midnight Mass with his wife. Sri Lankas top diplomat here, Devinda R. Subasinghe, didnt find out about the tsunami until 3:30 the following morning, when he was awakened by an urgent phone call by his duty officer. Thai Ambassador Kasit Piromya heard the news on CNN, while enjoying his last day of vacation in Buenos Aires.
"My first reaction was that we didnt know the extent of the damage, but I had a gut feeling it would be much worse," Piromya recalls. "My anticipation was quite correct."
Within days, the full extent of the tragedy would emergeand the four men would face the biggest challenge of their professional lives.
Last month, Brotodiningrat, Subasinghe and Piromya gathered at the Willard InterContinental Washington Hotel in an exclusive interview arranged by The Washington Diplomat, even as bodies were still being discovered in the aftermath of the Indian Ocean tsunami, which claimed an estimated 221,000 lives in 11 countries, as of press time, although a definitive death toll of the disaster may never be known.
Indonesia
Clearly, the brunt of the disaster was borne by Indonesia, where more than 160,000 deaths were reported just on the island of Sumatra. In Sri Lanka, the death toll surpassed 38,000, while the tsunami killed nearly 16,000 people in India and at least 5,000 in Thailand. Smaller numbers of deaths were reported in Malaysia, Bangladesh, Burma and the Maldives, as well as three East African countries: Somalia, Kenya and Tanzania.
"I am originally from a province far from the affected area, but if 110,000 of your countrymen suddenly die, of course it will affect your emotions," says Brotodiningrat. "Ive never experienced anything like this in my life."
Brotodiningrat estimated that rehabilitation and reconstruction of Sumatras devastated western coast will carry a price tag of around $1.3 billion. More recently, Indonesian officials told donors that the tsunami would likely cost the country as a whole around $4.5 billion. The psychological costs are incalculable.
"The people are still in a state of shock, but many of them will prefer to come back once everything is normal again, and we will help them to rebuild."
He says at least two employees of the Indonesian Embassy fronting Massachusetts Avenue lost families and relatives in the disaster, "adding to the collective emotions in our embassy."
In the wake of the disaster, governments around the world have pledged close to $4 billion in assistance, which does not include an additional $3 billion from private donations. (To date, donors have promised $739 million of the $977 million that the U.N. system says is needed in emergency aid to meet the basic needs of victims over the next six months.) As of press time, the leading donor nations were Australia ($810 million), Germany ($674 million), Japan ($500 million) and the United States ($350 million). In addition, the Islamic Development Bank has promised more than $400 million to help get Indonesia back on track.
"Being on the receiving end, we appreciate and will never forget those who helped us, even though we would like to maintain some level of dignity," says Brotodiningrat. "Unfortunately, Indonesia is a disaster-prone country, so we are used to this. But this was incomprehensible."
Even more incomprehensible is the idea that Muslim groups allied with al Qaeda would launch a terrorist attack against foreign aid workers in Aceh province, which for years has been waging a protracted war for independence against the Indonesian government.
But that threat exists, even though the Bush administration is betting that massive U.S. military and economic aid to tsunami victims will alleviate anti-American sentiment in Indonesia, the worlds most populous Muslim country.
"This tactic will only be effective if they dont say it. Just do it and people will judge," the ambassador says. "But if people see that what the United States is doing is motivated by something other than helping, Im afraid it will be counterproductive."
In the meantime, a tenuous informal ceasefire has been in place between Aceh rebels and the Indonesian military, although at least 120 rebels in the province have been killed following skirmishes with Indonesian military forces. Nevertheless, Brotodiningrat says hes so far encouraged by Aceh rebels who have agreed to let aid workers do their jobs free from interference.
"In the face of this very difficult situation, we are all brothers. For our part, we have already redirected all military operations toward disaster relief. On their side, we noted their statement that there was a ceasefire. Hopefully this will generate a more positive and continuing kind of rapprochement."
Sri Lanka
A similar situation exists in Sri Lanka, where a long-running civil war has killed more than 60,000 people over the last 20 years and forced the countrys once-prosperous economy to stagnate. Two years ago, the rebel Tamil Tigers agreed to temporarily end their violent campaign for a separate homeland in the northeastern part of the island for Sri Lankas 3.2 million ethnic Tamils.
Despite their differences, the Tigers have had extensive contact with the government to relieve the suffering of thousands of people who lost everything in the tsunami. Relief supplies are now getting into areas under rebel control, says Subasinghe.
"There was already an ongoing peace process, and by and large, that ceasefire was holding," he told The Diplomat. "The power of nature has manifested itself in a very epic form, and thats going to give us an opportunity to rise above all ethnic and political differences."
Close to 1 million Sri Lankans were left homeless by the big waves, which decimated 70 percent of the islands coastline and destroyed about 5,000 hotel roomsfurther damaging the countrys fragile economy, which is highly dependent on tourism.
Subasinghe says the U.S. Agency for International Development has a $10 million program in place to "get cash into peoples hands to clear the debris" and help rebuild homes and small businesses.
For Subasinghe, this disaster hits particularly hard because both his mother and father are from Galle, a town on Sri Lankas southern coast that was ripped apart by the tsunamis 30-foot waves.
"These were pristine villages and beaches, and its heart-wrenching to see the damage that has been caused," Subasinghe says. "Society is just completely wiped out in a flash."
Even so, he adds: "One always has to check ones emotions at the door. As I go about my work with the expatriate community and relief organizations, many people have called with expressions of condolence."
Subasinghe says between 60,000 and 100,000 Sri Lankans live in the United Statesabout 15,000 of them in the Washington areaand that many of them have sent money and supplies to help their homeland weather this crisis. The Sri Lanka Medical Association of North America and the Sri Lanka Association of Washington, D.C., have contributed generously, as have area Buddhist temples.
"This is a generous country and a compassionate country. Obviously, were thankful for all the support," he says.
In the days following the tsunami, several newspaper articles surfaced recounting how poor Sri Lankan tsunami survivors literally gave the shirts off their backs to European tourists who were stranded on the island with nothing to wear.
Subasinghe notes that "generosity works in both directions. There were also many tourists who decided to stay there and help the locals."
The ambassador denies earlier published reports that his government, which has a sizable Muslim minority, refused help from Israel in the days immediately following the tsunami.
"What happened was that Sri Lanka did issue a temporary halt to medical teams because we were overwhelmed and we needed to support them. It was not meant to be Israel-specific. An Israeli military team was ready to leave for Sri Lanka. We have since lifted that hold. We have had a very robust military relationship with Israel for many years."
Thailand
Of t he dozen countries struck by the disaster, Thailand is unique in that most of the victims were European tourists rather than locals.
"We had people from 30 countries in the area when it hit," says Ambassador Piromya. "It was the peak tourism season, and the area affected is the number-one tourism attraction in Thailand."
The tsunami killed untold thousands of foreignersmainly Swedes, Germans, Norwegians and Swisswho were vacationing at Thailands famous beaches.
"We are asking the relatives living in Europe and the United States to send DNA samples of themselves so we can match them with the bodies that have been recovered," Piromya says, explaining that this forensic testing will help to identify the many still unaccounted-for victims. "Everybody will have two examinations in order to ascertain whos who."
Piromya says "a few hundred thousand" Thais remain homeless in six coastal provinces, and that "a lot of countries have already sent ministerial-rank delegations in order to bring relief to their people."
Piromyawho along with the three other ambassadors received President Bush and former presidents Bill Clinton and George H.W. Bush at their respective embassiessays he was "extremely honored" by the unprecedented gesture.
Despite the immediate 20 percent to 30 percent loss in tourism revenues caused by the tsunami disaster, Piromya says Thailand expects to recover quickly, although he promised that his government would make financial aid to fisherman and other displaced people a priority over rebuilding hotels and other tourism infrastructure.
He also stressed the need for a tsunami warning system for the Indian Ocean similar to that which exists for nations bordering the Pacific Ocean.
"All of our heads of state have discussed this, and India has already taken the initiative to piggyback on seismological sensors they already have. We certainly need this. Whatever it costs, we must install it."
Since the disaster, Piromya says hes been overwhelmed by the outpouring of generosity arriving at the Royal Thai Embassy on Wisconsin Avenuefrom not only presidents and prime ministers but also ordinary people, including schoolchildren.
"The shared suffering is very important. Maybe it will make everyone think about the futility of killing," he says. "Im sure the Tamils in Sri Lanka and the Muslims in Indonesia cannot comprehend so minute a thing after this disaster. I hope it will have that positive effect."
India
In India, the tsunami unleashed its worst fury on the remote Andaman and Nicobar island groups, home to primitive tribes that are rarely visited by mainland Indians, let alone foreigners.
Ambassador Sen, who spoke by phone with The Diplomat, said much of his time is spent explaining to people why India refused humanitarian assistance in the wake of such a disaster.
"This is not about pride or prestige. No country in the world would have been able to respond as fast as we could," he says, noting that the Indian Navy sent seven vessels to Sri Lanka the same day the tsunami hit. Likewise, the first hospital ship to arrive in Indonesia belonged to India.
"We have confidence in our ability to handle the situation on our own. In terms of expertise and resources, youre not talking in terms of weeks or days, but hours," he says. "In Andaman and Nicobar, our air bases were virtually wiped out. Many airmen were killed, and aircraft was destroyed. Yet the few helicopter pilots who survived got airborne and immediately started search-and-rescue operations."
Sen says "absolutely no foreign" aid workers have been allowed onto those islands, for fear of destroying what little remains of some of the worlds most primitive, remote civilizations.
"The trauma they would face with foreigners would be as much if not higher than the tsunami itself. Ever since independence, weve been trying to protect them and preserve their way of life. You have to know how to approach these people. Even Indians are not allowed to go there without proper training."
With more than a billion inhabitants, India is the worlds second-most populous country. It also has a rapidly growing middle class and is making important inroads in several global industries, including petroleum, telecommunications and biotechnology.
"We are not a borrower but officially a creditor to the [International Monetary Fund]," says the ambassador. "We are giving hundreds of millions of dollars to less developed countries. We have already spent more than $400 million in Afghanistan, and weve written off the debts of many sub-Saharan African countries. The image of India thats stuck in peoples minds just doesnt correspond to reality."
Perhaps thats why, he says, in the wake of the tsunami disaster, "people send medicines to a country which produces medicines at a fraction of the price as here, and clothing to a country thats one of the worlds largest producers of textiles."
Cash donations are best, he says, although "more than 95 percent of what is collected will be from within India." As we went to press, the Prime Ministers National Relief Fund had raised more than $120 millionwith much of the money coming from the poorest sectors of society.
"Its not just money," Sen says. "Its a sense of sympathy and solidarity, which has been a very big source of solace and strength for us as we deal with these formidable challenges. Even as we speak, were continuing our assistance programs to neighboring countries whose plight is worse than ours. And you cant put a price tag on that."
Larry Luxner is a contributing writer for The Washington Diplomat.
|
|
|
|
|